When an ACL reconstruction fails, the most important question is not simply how to replace the graft -it is why the original reconstruction failed.

Recurrent instability may follow a new sporting injury, but it can also reflect unrecognised rotational instability, associated meniscal or ligament injury, tunnel position, graft factors or the underlying alignment of the knee.

Revision ACL reconstruction is therefore fundamentally different from a first-time reconstruction.

My approach begins with understanding the cause of failure before deciding on the next operation.

Assessment may include advanced imaging of previous tunnels, evaluation of meniscal and cartilage damage, examination of the collateral ligaments and posterolateral corner, and measurement of lower-limb alignment and posterior tibial slope.

In selected patients, revision surgery may require additional procedures such as lateral extra-articular tenodesis, meniscal repair, bone grafting, slope correction or coronal plane osteotomy or reconstruction of associated ligaments.

Some reconstructions can be performed in a single operation, while others require a staged approach.

The choice of graft and fixation strategy must also account for previous surgery and the remaining anatomical options.

The objective is not simply to perform another ACL reconstruction, but to address the reasons for failure and give the knee the best opportunity for durable stability.