Protecting Young Knees. Preserving Sporting Futures.
An ACL injury can be devastating for a young athlete. Beyond the physical injury, it can interrupt their sport, friendships, confidence and sense of identity -often at a critical stage in their development.
For talented junior athletes, the impact can be even greater. Representative selection, development pathways and aspirations for elite sport can all suddenly feel uncertain.
As a sports surgeon working with professional sporting teams and developing athletes, and as a parent of two active teenagers, I understand that an ACL injury in a young person is about much more than the knee.
The Growing Knee Is Different
ACL injuries in children and adolescents require a different approach from those in adults.
Skeletal maturity, open growth plates, ligament anatomy, associated meniscal injuries and future sporting demands all influence treatment decisions.
For younger patients with significant growth remaining, particular care is required when planning ACL reconstruction to minimise the risk of growth disturbance. Surgical techniques and graft selection must be tailored to the individual's stage of development.
Equally important is preserving the meniscus and articular cartilage wherever possible, protecting the long-term health of the knee.
The objective is not simply to reconstruct the ACL, but to protect a knee that still has decades of activity ahead of it.
The Risk of a Second ACL Injury
One of the greatest challenges in treating young athletes is their increased risk of sustaining another ACL injury.
Young athletes returning to pivoting and contact sports have substantially higher rates of subsequent ACL injury than older, less active populations. This may involve reinjury of the reconstructed ACL or a new injury to the opposite knee.
For this reason, I place particular emphasis on identifying and addressing factors that may contribute to reinjury.
These include graft selection, rotational instability, associated meniscal injury, lower-limb alignment, rehabilitation quality and readiness to return to sport.
In selected high-risk young athletes, additional procedures such as lateral extra-articular tenodesis (LET) may be considered to improve rotational stability and reduce the risk of graft failure.
There is no single reconstruction that is right for every young athlete. The surgical strategy must reflect their anatomy, skeletal maturity, sport and individual risk profile.
Returning to Sport Is Not Simply About Time
For a young athlete, the desire to return to sport can be enormous. There may be pressure to make a representative team, participate in a championship or avoid missing an important season.
However, biological healing, strength recovery, neuromuscular control and psychological readiness do not always progress at the same rate.
Returning too early can expose the athlete to an unacceptable risk of further injury.
I favour a criteria-based approach to return to sport, incorporating objective strength assessment, functional testing, movement quality, confidence and progressive exposure to sporting demands.
Time remains an important consideration, but it should never be the only measure of readiness.
The aim is to return the athlete when they are genuinely prepared for the demands of their sport - not simply when a date on the calendar has been reached.
Supporting the Athlete Beyond Surgery
The recovery journey can be particularly difficult for adolescents.
Missing training, watching teammates compete and feeling disconnected from their sporting community can affect motivation, confidence and wellbeing.
Young athletes need more than a technically successful reconstruction. They need clear communication, realistic expectations and a coordinated team supporting them through rehabilitation.
I believe strongly in involving the athlete, their family, physiotherapist, coaches and performance staff in the decision-making process.
The young athlete should understand their injury, feel involved in their treatment and remain connected to their sport throughout recovery wherever possible.
Looking Beyond the Next Season
My responsibility is not simply to get a young athlete back for the next game, final or representative selection.
It is to consider the long-term consequences of every decision -from whether surgery is required, through graft selection and meniscal preservation, to rehabilitation and return-to-sport planning.
The goal isn't simply to get a young athlete back for the next season. It's to give them the best opportunity to enjoy sport, perform at their potential and remain active for years to come.
Book an appointment
Discuss your young athlete's ACL injury with A/Prof Peter D’Alessandro.












