ACL INJURIES: Every ACL Injury Is Different.

An ACL injury can be a defining moment for an athlete, but the diagnosis is only the beginning. Understanding the injury, the individual and their sporting ambitions is essential to making the right decisions about treatment and recovery. Not every ACL injury requires surgery, and not every ACL reconstruction should be the same.

My approach begins with a comprehensive assessment of the entire knee — including associated meniscal, cartilage and ligament injuries, rotational stability, alignment and individual risk factors. Age, skeletal maturity, sporting demands and previous injuries all influence the treatment strategy.

For some patients, structured rehabilitation and non-operative management may be appropriate. For the majority, particularly those returning to high-demand pivoting sports or experiencing persistent instability, surgical reconstruction offers the best opportunity to restore stability and function.

Where surgery is required, decisions around graft selection, meniscal preservation, additional stabilisation procedures and rehabilitation should be tailored to the individual rather than following a standard formula.

The goal isn’t simply to reconstruct a ligament. It’s to restore a stable, functional knee, protect its long-term health and give every athlete the best opportunity to return to what matters to them.

A/Prof Peter D’Alessandro provides assessment and treatment for ACL injuries in Claremont, Murdoch, Lathlain, Dunsborough, regional WA and Perth, with treatment tailored to the individual and their sporting goals.

What is an ACL injury?

The anterior cruciate ligament connects the femur (thigh bone) to the tibia (shin bone) inside the knee. It helps control excessive forward movement of the tibia and contributes to rotational stability during activities such as running, landing and changing direction.

An ACL injury may range from a partial ligament injury to a complete tear. The injury may occur on its own or together with damage to the meniscus, cartilage or other knee ligaments.

What causes an ACL tear?

An ACL injury commonly occurs when the knee is subjected to a sudden change in movement or load. Typical situations include:

  • Pivoting or changing direction rapidly
  • Suddenly slowing down while running
  • Landing awkwardly from a jump
  • Stopping or decelerating with the foot planted
  • A direct impact or collision involving the knee

These injuries are common in football, soccer, netball, basketball and other sports requiring repeated cutting, jumping and rapid changes of direction.

Who is at risk of an ACL injury?

ACL injuries can affect recreational athletes, competitive players and people who participate in physically demanding activities.

Risk can be influenced by factors such as:

  • Participation in pivoting or high-speed sports
  • Previous ACL or knee injury
  • Training and movement patterns
  • Muscle strength and neuromuscular control
  • The demands placed on the knee during sport

ACL injuries are also common among adolescent athletes, making careful assessment particularly important when the growth plates are still open.

How can an ACL injury affect you?

A torn ACL can affect the way your knee responds to movements that require stability and rotation. Some people experience repeated episodes of the knee giving way, particularly during sport.

Instability may limit activities such as running, cutting, jumping and changing direction. An ACL injury may also occur alongside meniscal or cartilage damage, which can influence both treatment decisions and longer-term knee health.

For an athlete, the impact is therefore not simply whether the ligament is torn. The more important question is whether the knee can safely meet the demands of the activities you want to perform.

What are the symptoms of an ACL tear?

Common symptoms following an ACL injury include:

  • A popping sensation or sound at the time of injury
  • Rapid swelling of the knee
  • Pain and difficulty continuing activity
  • A feeling that the knee has given way
  • Reduced range of movement
  • Instability during twisting or changes of direction

Not everyone experiences all of these symptoms. A knee injury that causes significant swelling, instability or difficulty bearing weight should be assessed promptly.

How is an ACL injury diagnosed?

Diagnosis begins with a detailed assessment of how the injury occurred, your symptoms and your sporting or activity requirements.

A physical examination helps assess knee movement and stability. Specific clinical tests can be used to assess the function of the ACL, including the Lachman and pivot-shift tests.

Imaging may include:

  • X-rays to assess the bones and identify associated fractures or other abnormalities
  • MRI scans to assess the ACL and identify associated meniscal, cartilage or other ligament injuries

The MRI findings are considered alongside the clinical examination rather than in isolation. Understanding how the knee functions and what you want to return to is important when determining the most appropriate treatment.

How are ACL injuries treated?

Treatment is individualised according to the stability of your knee, the nature of the injury, associated damage and your activity or sporting goals.

Non-surgical ACL treatment

Some people can manage an ACL injury without reconstruction, particularly when the knee remains functionally stable and their activities do not place high demands on pivoting or rapid changes of direction.

Non-surgical management may include:

  • Physiotherapy to restore knee movement and strength
  • Progressive strengthening of the quadriceps, hamstrings and surrounding muscles
  • Balance and neuromuscular training
  • Sport-specific rehabilitation
  • Modification of activities during recovery
  • Bracing in selected circumstances

The aim is to develop a knee that is stable and functional for the activities that matter to you. Some people can return to an active lifestyle without ACL reconstruction, while others continue to experience instability despite rehabilitation.

ACL reconstruction

ACL reconstruction may be considered when the knee remains unstable, particularly in people who want to return to sports involving pivoting, cutting, jumping or rapid changes of direction.

During ACL reconstruction, the torn ACL is replaced with a tendon graft. The choice of graft and whether additional procedures are required depend on individual factors, including age, activity level, previous surgery, sporting goals and associated knee injuries.

Graft options may include:

  • Patellar tendon
  • Hamstring tendon
  • Quadriceps tendon
  • Other selected autograft options

There is no single graft or surgical approach that is appropriate for every patient. The decision should take into account the individual's knee, sporting requirements and long-term goals.

ACL injuries with associated knee damage

An ACL tear may occur together with a meniscal tear, cartilage injury or damage to another ligament. When this occurs, treatment may need to address more than the ACL alone.

Where appropriate, preserving and repairing the meniscus and addressing other structural injuries may form part of the overall treatment plan.

ACL injuries in children and teenagers

ACL injuries require particular consideration in growing athletes because the growth plates are still developing.

Treatment needs to take into account the child's skeletal maturity, knee stability, sporting goals and any associated injuries. In selected patients, specialised surgical techniques may be considered to minimise disruption to the growth plates.

The decision between rehabilitation and surgery should be individualised rather than based on age alone.

What can you expect after ACL treatment?

Recovery depends on the treatment approach, the severity of the injury and whether other structures within the knee have also been injured.

Following ACL reconstruction, rehabilitation is a major part of recovery. It typically progresses through stages that focus on:

  • Reducing pain and swelling
  • Restoring knee movement
  • Regaining strength
  • Developing balance and neuromuscular control
  • Progressing to running and sport-specific activities
  • Assessing readiness for return to sport

Return to sport should be based on functional recovery and appropriate clinical criteria rather than simply the amount of time that has passed. ACL rehabilitation commonly takes many months, with sports-medicine guidance recommending a structured progression before returning to competitive activity.

Can an ACL tear heal without surgery?

Some ACL injuries can be managed without reconstruction. This may be appropriate when the knee is functionally stable and the person's activity demands can be met through rehabilitation.

However, an individual who wants to return to sports involving frequent pivoting or rapid changes of direction may have different treatment requirements. The decision should consider knee stability, associated injuries, sporting demands and personal goals.

Can you play sport after an ACL tear?

Returning to sport is possible for many people following appropriate ACL rehabilitation, with or without reconstruction depending on the individual circumstances.

The type of sport matters. Activities involving cutting, pivoting and rapid changes of direction place greater demands on an ACL-deficient or reconstructed knee than lower-demand activities.

A return-to-sport programme should therefore progress from basic strength and movement to running, change of direction and sport-specific skills before competitive participation.

What happens if an ACL tear is left untreated?

An untreated ACL tear does not necessarily require surgery in every person. However, persistent instability can make some activities difficult and may increase the risk of further knee injury during episodes of giving way.

Associated meniscal or cartilage injuries may also affect the longer-term health and function of the knee.

For this reason, the decision to observe, rehabilitate or reconstruct an ACL should consider both your current symptoms and your longer-term activity and knee-health goals.

Your ACL treatment should be based on your goals

An ACL tear is not simply an MRI diagnosis. The most appropriate treatment depends on how your knee functions, the demands you place on it and what you want to return to.

Whether your goal is returning to competitive sport, recreational activity or everyday movement, assessment can help determine whether rehabilitation, ACL reconstruction or another treatment approach is appropriate.

A/Prof Peter D’Alessandro provides ACL injury assessment and treatment for patients in Claremont, Murdoch, Lathlain, Dunsborough, regional WA and Perth.

ACL Injuries

Book an appointment

Discuss your injury, treatment options and pathway back to the activities that matter to you with A/Prof Peter D’Alessandro.

Book an Appointment

Ready to get moving again?

I bring that same approach to every patient, whether returning to professional competition, weekend sport or simply an active life. Research, innovation and teaching remain central to my practice – not simply to follow where sports surgery is going, but to help shape what comes next.

And the ‘sports tragic’ part? You’ll find me at CrossFit Claremont at 5:30 every morning, while each weekend is spent with Tash, Sienna and Josh at Optus Stadium and Matthews watching footy, netball or pretty much anything involving a ball or a competition.

Sport is part of who I am. My job is to get you back to doing what matters to you.

Contact the Practice

Book an Appointment | Explore Expertise