ACL Graft Choice
THE RIGHT GRAFT FOR THE RIGHT ATHLETE
One ACL. Several Options. No Single Best Graft.
Choosing the right graft is one of the most important decisions in ACL reconstruction. Different grafts have different strengths, limitations and potential effects on recovery, muscle function and future sporting performance.
There is no single graft that is best for every patient.
My approach is to individualise graft selection according to the athlete’s age, sport, activity demands, anatomy, associated injuries, previous surgery and personal priorities. I am passionate about using all graft options, in the right scenario, for the right patient, rather than simply using the same graft for everyone.
For a young footballer or netballer returning to high-demand pivoting sport, the considerations may be very different from those of a recreational runner, an older active patient or an athlete undergoing revision reconstruction.
Importantly, graft choice is not simply about how strong the new ACL will be. It is also about the consequences of harvesting the graft, preserving muscle function, reducing donor-site morbidity and protecting the reconstruction over time.
Understanding Your Graft Options
Each graft has different advantages and trade-offs. The right choice depends on the individual athlete and the overall reconstruction strategy.
Patellar Tendon Autograft (BTB)
Bone–patellar tendon–bone grafts have a long history of successful use, particularly in young athletes participating in high-demand pivoting and contact sports. The graft incorporates bone plugs at each end, allowing bone-to-bone healing within the reconstruction tunnels.
This is one of the graft options I regularly use for selected higher-risk athletes, given its established track record and favourable failure rates in appropriate populations. However, no graft is universally best.
Harvesting the central portion of the patellar tendon can be associated with anterior knee pain, kneeling discomfort and other donor-site symptoms. For some athletes, these trade-offs may be acceptable; for others, they may influence the choice of graft.
Hamstring Tendon Autograft
Hamstring tendon grafts are widely used in ACL reconstruction and offer reliable outcomes without harvesting tissue from the knee’s extensor mechanism. This is the most common graft used in Australia.
Traditional techniques commonly use both the semitendinosus and gracilis tendons. However, harvesting these tendons can affect hamstring strength, particularly knee flexion strength at deeper angles.
Our research through the DOSTAR randomised controlled trial is investigating whether using a single semitendinosus tendon can reduce donor-site morbidity and better preserve hamstring function while maintaining the benefits of ACL reconstruction.
Explore DOSTAR ResearchQuadriceps Tendon Autograft
The quadriceps tendon provides a strong, versatile graft and is increasingly used in primary and revision ACL reconstruction. It avoids hamstring tendon harvest and may be particularly useful in selected athletes, depending on their sporting demands, anatomy and previous procedures.
Potential considerations include anterior knee discomfort and temporary quadriceps weakness during rehabilitation.
I often use quadriceps tendon grafts for martial artists and patients with higher-grade MCL injuries.
Peroneus Longus Tendon Autograft
An Alternative Autograft That Preserves the Hamstrings and Knee Extensor Mechanism
The peroneus longus tendon provides an alternative autograft option for ACL reconstruction, using the patient’s own tendon harvested from the lower leg around the ankle.
A particular advantage is the ability to reduce the functional consequences of harvesting graft tissue from around the knee, particularly where preserving hamstring or quadriceps function is a priority, or where conventional graft options are less suitable.
However, harvesting the peroneus longus tendon introduces different considerations, including potential effects on ankle strength, eversion function and stability. Longer-term comparative evidence remains more limited than for established ACL graft options.
Allograft (Donor Tissue)
Allograft uses donor tendon tissue, avoiding the need to harvest a patient’s own tendon. It may have a role in selected revision or complex reconstructions, or in carefully chosen lower-demand patients.
However, allograft has been associated with higher failure rates in young, active athletes and is not my preferred option for primary ACL reconstruction in this group.
Preserving Function Matters
An ACL reconstruction should restore knee stability without unnecessarily compromising the structures and muscle function that athletes depend upon.
This is particularly relevant to hamstring graft harvest, where the consequences may extend beyond the knee itself to sprinting, acceleration, deceleration and other high-demand sporting activities.
Our DOSTAR study reflects this philosophy: questioning whether traditional graft-harvesting techniques can be refined to reduce morbidity and preserve function without compromising the reconstruction.
Explore the DOSTAR ACL ResearchThe DOSTAR Study: A Double-Blinded Randomised Controlled Trial Comparing Dual and Single Tendon Hamstring Grafts.
More Than the Graft
Graft selection is only one component of successful ACL reconstruction.
Tunnel positioning, fixation, meniscal preservation, rotational stability, associated ligament injuries, alignment, rehabilitation and return-to-sport decision-making all contribute to the overall outcome. In selected higher-risk athletes, additional procedures such as lateral extra-articular tenodesis (LET) may be considered to improve rotational stability and reduce the risk of graft failure.
The right graft must therefore be considered as part of the entire surgical strategy — not as an isolated decision.
Making the Decision Together
I believe patients should understand not only which graft I recommend, but why I recommend it for them. That discussion includes the available evidence, the potential benefits and disadvantages of each option, the demands of their sport and their individual priorities.
The objective is not simply to choose a graft that reconstructs the ACL. It is to choose a reconstruction strategy that restores stability, preserves function and gives the athlete the best opportunity for a successful long-term outcome.












