Treatment for Meniscal Tears

Partial meniscectomy is a surgical procedure used to remove the damaged or unstable portion of a torn meniscus while preserving as much healthy meniscal tissue as possible.

It may be considered when a meniscal tear is causing persistent symptoms and the damaged portion cannot be appropriately repaired. Treatment is based on the location, length and pattern of the tear, as well as the patient's symptoms and overall knee condition.

Who May Be Suitable for Partial Meniscectomy?

Partial meniscectomy may be considered for patients with a symptomatic meniscal tear when non-surgical treatment has not provided adequate relief and the damaged portion is not suitable for repair.

Treatment decisions take into account:

  • Location of the tear
  • Length and pattern of the tear
  • Symptoms and functional limitations
  • Stability of the remaining meniscus
  • Associated knee conditions
  • Activity and sporting requirements

Whenever possible, healthy meniscal tissue is preserved.

What Is Partial Meniscectomy?

The menisci are wedge-shaped pieces of fibrocartilage between the thighbone and shinbone. They help with load distribution, cushioning and stability of the knee.

A partial meniscectomy removes only the torn or unstable portion of the meniscus rather than removing the entire meniscus.

The procedure is usually performed using knee arthroscopy, allowing the surgeon to view and treat the inside of the knee through small incisions.

Potential Benefits

Partial meniscectomy may help:

  • Remove unstable or damaged meniscal tissue
  • Address pain associated with the tear
  • Reduce catching or locking symptoms
  • Improve knee movement and function
  • Preserve the remaining healthy meniscal tissue

The expected outcome depends on the type of tear and the overall condition of the knee.

How Is Partial Meniscectomy Performed?

Partial meniscectomy is performed using arthroscopic techniques.

The procedure generally involves:

  • Small incisions are made around the knee.
  • An arthroscope is inserted through one of the incisions.
  • The inside of the knee is examined.
  • The meniscus is assessed to identify the torn and unstable portion.
  • Small surgical instruments are inserted through additional incisions.
  • The damaged portion of the meniscus is carefully removed.
  • Unstable fragments that may contribute to catching or locking are removed.
  • The remaining meniscal edges are smoothed where appropriate.
  • The knee is assessed following treatment.
  • The instruments are removed and the small incisions are closed and dressed.

The aim is to remove the damaged tissue while preserving as much functional meniscus as possible.

Prognosis and Recovery

Recovery following partial meniscectomy varies according to the extent of the procedure and the condition of the knee.

Rehabilitation may be recommended to help restore:

  • Knee movement
  • Strength
  • Range of motion
  • Functional capacity

Your recovery programme will be guided by your symptoms, knee function and individual activity goals.

Preparing for Partial Meniscectomy

Before surgery, your knee will be assessed to confirm the nature of the meniscal injury and determine whether partial meniscectomy is appropriate.

Your assessment may include:

  • Review of your symptoms and medical history
  • Clinical examination
  • Review of relevant imaging
  • Assessment of the meniscal tear
  • Evaluation of associated knee problems
  • Discussion of non-surgical and surgical treatment options
  • Discussion of your activity and sporting goals

Your surgeon will provide specific instructions regarding preparation for surgery and postoperative recovery.

Risks and Complications

As with any surgical procedure, partial meniscectomy carries potential risks and complications. These may include:

  • Infection
  • Bleeding
  • Injury to nerves or blood vessels
  • Blood clots
  • Anaesthetic complications
  • Persistent symptoms or stiffness
  • Ongoing or recurrent knee problems

Your individual risks will be discussed during your consultation.

Partial Meniscectomy for Active Patients

For active patients and athletes, treatment decisions need to consider both current symptoms and the long-term condition of the knee.

Where repair is appropriate, meniscal preservation may be preferred. When the damaged portion cannot be repaired, partial meniscectomy may provide an option for addressing unstable meniscal tissue while preserving the remaining meniscus.

Rehabilitation and return to activity are tailored to the individual and the demands of their sport or lifestyle.

Specialist Partial Meniscectomy in Perth and Western Australia

A/Prof Peter D’Alessandro provides specialist assessment and arthroscopic treatment for meniscal injuries, including partial meniscectomy where appropriate.

Treatment is tailored to the individual tear and the condition of the knee, with preservation of healthy meniscal tissue considered whenever possible.

Partial Meniscectomy

Book an appointment

Discuss your meniscal tear and treatment options with A/Prof Peter D’Alessandro.

Book an Appointment

Ready to get moving again?

I bring that same approach to every patient, whether returning to professional competition, weekend sport or simply an active life. Research, innovation and teaching remain central to my practice – not simply to follow where sports surgery is going, but to help shape what comes next.

And the ‘sports tragic’ part? You’ll find me at CrossFit Claremont at 5:30 every morning, while each weekend is spent with Tash, Sienna and Josh at Optus Stadium and Matthews watching footy, netball or pretty much anything involving a ball or a competition.

Sport is part of who I am. My job is to get you back to doing what matters to you.

Contact the Practice

Book an Appointment | Explore Expertise