Treatment for Meniscal Deficiency and Persistent Knee Pain

Meniscal transplantation is a surgical procedure that replaces a damaged or previously removed meniscus with donor meniscal tissue.

The menisci play an important role in cushioning the knee and contributing to its stability. When a significant portion of the meniscus has been removed and a patient continues to experience activity-related knee pain, meniscal transplantation may be considered in carefully selected patients.

Who May Be Suitable for Meniscal Transplantation?

Meniscal transplantation is not suitable for everyone with a meniscal tear or previous meniscectomy. The client criteria for consideration include:

  • Young to middle-aged patients, generally below 50 years of age
  • A stable and well-aligned knee
  • Intact or minimally damaged articular cartilage
  • Previous meniscectomy
  • Persistent activity-related knee pain

Meniscal transplantation is generally not recommended when there are severe arthritic changes within the knee.

A detailed assessment is required to determine whether transplantation is appropriate.

What Is Meniscal Transplantation?

Each knee contains two menisci, one on the inner side, known as the medial meniscus, and one on the outer side, known as the lateral meniscus. The menisci help cushion the knee and contribute to joint stability.

Meniscal transplantation involves replacing deficient or previously removed meniscal tissue with donor meniscal tissue. The donor tissue is prepared to fit the patient's knee and secured in position during surgery.

The aim is to address persistent pain associated with meniscal deficiency and help protect the function of the knee.

Potential Benefits of Meniscal Transplantation

For appropriately selected patients, meniscal transplantation may:

  • Reduce activity-related knee pain
  • Restore meniscal tissue to the knee
  • Support knee function and stability
  • Help protect the knee from further joint changes
  • Support a return to physical and sporting activities

Outcomes depend on patient selection, the condition of the knee and any associated procedures required.

Meniscal Transplantation Approaches

Donor Meniscal Tissue

The transplanted meniscus is obtained from a deceased donor and prepared to fit the patient's knee.

Arthroscopic Meniscal Transplantation

The procedure is generally performed using arthroscopic techniques to visualise the inside of the knee. The damaged or deficient meniscal tissue is addressed, and the donor meniscus is positioned and secured within the knee.

Additional Procedures

Depending on the condition of the knee, additional procedures may be performed at the same time, including treatment of associated ligament or cartilage problems.

How Is Meniscal Transplantation Performed?

Meniscal transplantation is performed under general anaesthesia. The procedure generally involves:

  • The knee is prepared for surgery and anaesthesia is administered.
  • Arthroscopy is used to assess the inside of the knee.
  • The damaged or deficient meniscal tissue is addressed.
  • The knee is prepared to receive the donor meniscus.
  • The donor meniscus is positioned in the appropriate location.
  • The transplant is secured to the surrounding tissue.
  • Additional fixation may be used to secure the transplanted meniscus.
  • Associated ligament or cartilage procedures may be performed where required.
  • The knee is assessed following completion of the procedure.
  • The incisions are closed and dressed.

The exact surgical approach depends on the condition of the knee and the individual patient's requirements.

Prognosis and Recovery

Recovery following meniscal transplantation requires a period of protection and rehabilitation to allow the transplanted tissue to heal.

Postoperative care may include:

  • Use of a knee brace for a period determined by the surgical team
  • Crutches to reduce stress on the operated knee
  • Progressive restoration of knee movement
  • Pain management
  • Physiotherapy to restore strength and function

The time required to return to work, or sport varies according to the individual's recovery and the demands of their activities. The current client information indicates that return to sport may take approximately 6 to 12 months.

Your rehabilitation programme and progression will be individualised according to your surgery and recovery.

Preparing for Meniscal Transplantation

Before surgery, your knee will be carefully assessed to determine whether meniscal transplantation is appropriate.

Assessment may include:

  • Medical history and review of symptoms
  • Physical examination
  • Assessment of knee stability and alignment
  • Assessment of the condition of the articular cartilage
  • X-rays to assess the bones and identify degenerative changes
  • MRI to assess the meniscus and other structures within the knee
  • Review of previous meniscal surgery

The suitability of transplantation depends on the overall condition of the knee rather than the meniscus alone.

Risks and Complications

As with any surgical procedure, meniscal transplantation has potential risks and complications, including:

  • Knee stiffness
  • Persistent pain
  • Infection
  • Bleeding
  • Nerve injury
  • Tearing of the transplanted meniscus
  • Incomplete healing
  • Transplant dysfunction
  • Weakness of the knee
  • Small risk of disease transmission from donor tissue

Your individual risks will be discussed during your consultation.

Specialist Meniscal Transplantation in Perth and Western Australia

A/Prof Peter D’Alessandro provides specialist assessment for patients with meniscal deficiency and persistent activity-related knee pain.

Meniscal transplantation is considered only when the characteristics of the patient and knee make the procedure appropriate. Assessment considers knee stability, alignment, articular cartilage, previous meniscal surgery and the patient's activity goals.

Knee Mensical Transplant

Meniscal Transplant

Book an appointment

Discuss whether meniscal transplantation may be appropriate for your knee with A/Prof Peter D’Alessandro.

Book an Appointment

Ready to get moving again?

I bring that same approach to every patient, whether returning to professional competition, weekend sport or simply an active life. Research, innovation and teaching remain central to my practice – not simply to follow where sports surgery is going, but to help shape what comes next.

And the ‘sports tragic’ part? You’ll find me at CrossFit Claremont at 5:30 every morning, while each weekend is spent with Tash, Sienna and Josh at Optus Stadium and Matthews watching footy, netball or pretty much anything involving a ball or a competition.

Sport is part of who I am. My job is to get you back to doing what matters to you.

Contact the Practice

Book an Appointment | Explore Expertise